Don’t measure GEO by traffic
Key takeaways
- In Marie Haynes’s data from 100 websites, AI traffic was 0.73% of the traffic from Google organic search. In The SEO Works’ data from 95 websites, it was 2.6% of organic traffic.
- AI shapes a B2B buyer’s supplier shortlist before anyone clicks, so traffic tells you little about the impact of generative engine optimisation (GEO).
- Whether AI visitors convert better or worse than other visitors depends on the dataset and the channel they’re compared with. In The SEO Works’ data, AI visitors to B2B product companies (10 websites) converted worse than organic visitors.
- You can see the impact in three places: AI answers, what customers tell you themselves, and sales.
- What matters is whether AI sells your company when buyers compare their options.
On 21 October 2026, SEO expert Marie Haynes published an article arguing that GEO is a distraction. She analysed 12 months of GA4 data from 100 websites, more than 145 million sessions in total. All AI services combined sent 0.73% as much traffic as Google organic search. For ChatGPT alone, the figure was 0.62%.
We don’t dispute the numbers, but we disagree with the conclusion. AI shapes a B2B buyer’s supplier shortlist before anyone clicks anything. So if you measure GEO by traffic, it will always look pointless. Here’s what your leadership team should track.
How much traffic does AI send, and does it convert?
UK search agency The SEO Works analysed data from 95 websites covering September 2025 to August 2026. Over the whole period, AI services sent the equivalent of 2.6% of organic search traffic, and in August 2026 the figure was 3.86%. The two datasets measure different things: in Haynes’s data, traffic referred by ChatGPT has fallen since August 2025, while in The SEO Works’ data the share from all AI services has risen since May 2026. In both datasets, though, the traffic is small. The SEO Works’ data is free to download; Haynes hasn’t published hers. Both sell search services, and so do we.
Advocates of AI traffic often point to its quality. According to The SEO Works, figures circulating in the industry claim that AI visitors convert 4.4 or even 23 times better than organic visitors. Even in Haynes’s data, visitors from ChatGPT converted at 13.8%, compared with 3.02% for Google organic search. Even so, AI produced few conversions: across the 55 websites that tracked conversions, organic search accounted for 964 and all AI services combined for 36.
The multiplier depends on what you compare it with. In The SEO Works’ comparison of 63 websites, visitors from AI converted at 7.18% and visitors from organic search at 6.08%, a multiplier of 1.18. Against paid search, the same AI traffic had a multiplier of 0.67, and against direct traffic 2.48. On 37% of the websites, AI traffic converted worse than organic. For B2B service companies, the multiplier was 1.21 (24 websites); for B2B product companies, it was 0.62 (10 websites).
So treat every multiplier with suspicion, including the ones we quote. Ask which channel the figure is compared with and how many websites are behind it.
AI answers are where buyers build their shortlist
A B2B buyer asks AI who can solve their problem and notes down the names from the answer. The enquiries go to the companies on that list, and none of it shows up as AI traffic. If your company isn’t on the list, the requests for quotes go elsewhere.
Our own data tells a similar story. In our OtterlyAI tracking from 1 to 19 October 2026, AI mentioned us in 248 of 952 answers to buyer questions (26%). From June to September 2026, our analytics recorded 1–6 sessions a month from AI services. The periods are different, but the gap is plain to see: AI mentions us in one answer in four, yet sends only a few sessions a month to our website.
Some AI search also happens inside Google. A visitor who arrives from an AI answer in Google shows up in analytics as ordinary organic traffic, and neither Haynes nor The SEO Works counts it as AI traffic. So the figures in both studies are a floor for AI traffic.
Many hope the impact will show up later as direct traffic or branded searches. Kevin Indig tested this in an analysis published on 19 October 2026, using data from four brands and 632 tests, and found no reliable link. In his data from 12 websites, direct traffic grew by 140.9%, but engaged direct sessions, in which the visitor actually did something on the site, fell by 1.0%, so the growth was mostly bots. The SEO Works’ data showed the same: once overall website growth was accounted for, growth in AI traffic didn’t show up as growth in direct traffic. The impact may be real, but you won’t find it in your analytics.
How do you measure GEO and AI visibility?
You measure AI visibility by putting the same buyer questions to AI assistants month after month and tracking whether they mention your company, where they rank you in the answer and why. Alongside that, you need customers’ own accounts of where they heard about your company, and your sales figures.
Tracking starts with a goal. First decide what AI should say about your company and in which buying situations, then phrase the questions you’ll track in your buyers’ own words. After that, look at three things together.
What AI says about your company and your competitors. When a buyer uses AI to compare options, the AI acts as your salesperson. Every month, MEOM tracks whether AI sells Finnish B2B companies. With our partner OtterlyAI, we look at answers from seven AI services: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode. The reporting stays the same even if the tool changes. We use six metrics to show how well AI is selling your company:
- Mention rate: the share of answers that mention your company.
- First mention: how often your company is the first name in the answer.
- Whether AI sells your company: does it recommend you for the reasons you would give yourself, or mention you neutrally or with reservations?
- Citations: whether AI uses your own website as a source for its answer.
- Buyer journey stage: at which stages of the buyer journey your company is mentioned, and where it drops out.
- Competitor share: how often your competitors are mentioned in the same answers.
AI answers vary each time you ask, so a single measurement tells you little. We separate real change from noise by tracking over several months.
What customers tell you themselves. On your contact form and in the first sales call, ask where the customer heard about your company, and add AI as one of the options on the form. Buyers often remember where they first came across your name. Asking about the lead source systematically is a low-cost way to make the impact of AI visible.
Leads and deals. Is the change showing up in sales? In Haynes’s data, 45 of the 100 websites weren’t tracking a single conversion. For many companies, then, tracking enquiries is the first step. Start by deciding what counts as a conversion on your B2B website, so you know what to track.
When all three move in the same direction, you have stronger evidence than any single number can give you.
Haynes is half right
Haynes is right that GEO is a distraction if all it chases is traffic. The goal of GEO is for AI to sell your company when buyers compare their options. When that happens, the selling starts before the buyer has even visited your website.
An answer that sells comes largely from the same work that improves search visibility. In The SEO Works’ data from 61 websites, AI traffic and organic search tended to grow together (correlation +0.557). The SEO Works’ reading is that the same groundwork lifts both: a clearly defined business, consistent information and credibility elsewhere on the web. In our view, the same work also determines what AI says about your company. It starts with pages that show buyers who you work for and why they should choose you. Tracking shows us whether the work is paying off in AI answers too.
In our ongoing GEO service, we go through the results with our customers every month. We explain why AI leaves a company out, what the numbers mean and what to tackle first. If you’d like to know whether AI is selling your company right now, book a free 30-minute GEO assessment and we’ll look at it together.
Sources
- Marie Haynes: GEO is a distraction, 21 October 2026.
- The SEO Works: How Much Traffic Do AI Assistants Actually Send, And Does It Convert Better?, updated 14 October 2026.
- Kevin Indig: Does AI drive more direct traffic?, Growth Memo, 19 October 2026.